A Flash in the Sky: The Lovettsville Plane Crash of 1940
The Day the Sky Fell Silent
It was late afternoon on August 31, 1940, when residents of Lovettsville, Virginia, heard a sound that would haunt them for decades—a roaring engine, a blinding flash of lightning, and then a deafening crash. In moments, a peaceful field west of Short Hill Mountain became the site of one of the worst air disasters in U.S. history.
Pennsylvania Central Airlines Flight 19, a newly minted Douglas DC‑3, had vanished from the sky. All 25 souls aboard perished, including a U.S. Senator, two FBI agents, and seasoned crew.
What Witnesses Saw
According to news accounts and personal testimony at the time, a bright flash of lightning preceded the crash. People thought the plane had been struck. A farmer named C. W. Bailey recalled the plane idling westward over Short Hill, then turning sharply back with its engines roaring. “Just a few seconds later,” he said, “I heard a terrific crash.”
Nearby, a young farm boy, Warren McGaha, said the plane “went straight down,” although he could still hear the engines. One witness described seeing a “blueish white flame as big as a house.”
In the stormy dusk, townspeople rushed toward the wreckage through mud and pasture—hoping to help, but there were no survivors.
Who Was On Board
Among the dead was Senator Ernest Lundeen of Minnesota. His presence on the flight added a political layer to the tragedy: Lundeen was under FBI investigation for his links to a suspected Nazi agent. Also killed were two FBI agents and a Justice Department prosecutor.
The aircraft’s pilot, Capt. Lowell Scroggins, was a highly experienced flier, with over 11,000 hours in the air. He had just passed his most recent flight check with a numerical rating of 92. This was no novice crew, and the plane itself had only flown 565 hours since being delivered new that May.
Cause: A Mystery in the Storm
The Civil Aeronautics Board launched an investigation—the first of its kind under the new federal air safety regulations. The aircraft showed no signs of mechanical failure, sabotage, or fire.
The board concluded that lightning most likely struck the aircraft, possibly disabling the crew or damaging critical systems.
The crash forced the aviation industry to confront the risks of flying through electrical storms—risks that, until then, were not fully understood.
The Impact on Lovettsville
For the quiet rural town of Lovettsville, the event marked an end to the summer harvest and the beginning of a darker season of memory. The story of Flight 19 remains embedded in the soil, the sky, and in the hearts of those who still farm near Short Hill.
Today, the Lovettsville Historical Society honors the memory of those lost and preserves this powerful story. The crash is more than a footnote in aviation history—it’s a moment when technology, nature, and fate collided over Western Loudoun.
Why We Remember
We tell these stories not to dwell on loss, but to recognize the resilience of small communities and how national tragedies ripple through local lives.
At Enchanted Green Acres, we believe history isn’t just in textbooks. It’s in the dirt under our boots, the ridgeline on the horizon, and sometimes in the sudden silence after a flash in the sky.
© 2025 Terry Housel. All rights reserved.
This work may not be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form without prior written permission from the author, except for brief quotations in reviews or scholarly works.
